Live video call online: answering the standard complaint
The complaint deserves a fair statement before an answer, so here it is at full strength.
The complaint
It goes: you talk to somebody for ninety seconds, you can never find them again, nothing follows, nothing accumulates. Set against an evening spent on something that builds — a friendship, a skill, a piece of work — it is time that produced nothing at all.
Nothing stupid about it. I would have raised the same objection myself, and each part of the description holds.
Two answers that do not work
- That you might meet somebody important. It happens about as rarely as the complaint implies, and defending the format on those grounds is dishonest.
- That the conversations are deep. Most are not, the median is two minutes of nothing much, and that figure is not about to improve.
The answer that does
Everything else an evening might hold rests on lasting acquaintance: whoever you are talking to will be around in the morning, and each of you is addressing the future edition of the other. That is the thing that makes ordinary talk careful.
Remove that and what stands is not a damaged version of ordinary talk. It is the one widespread form of conversation where nobody is steering an acquaintance while speaking, and I have looked for a substitute without finding one.
The honest limit
An hour that was going to stay empty gets filled; an hour that wanted something else does not, and which sort sits in front of you is knowledge you hold alone.
The whole defence rests on that distinction. It is a small one, and whoever offers you a bigger defence is selling you something.